Analysts linked the manipulations with voting in Kaspiysk to the problem of personal data protection.
Manipulations with the accounts of residents of Kaspiysk on "Gosuslugi" raise questions about the security of personal data and the reliability of voting results, analysts interviewed by "Kavkazsky Uzel" noted. A lawyer considered the punishment assigned to three officials, an MFC employee, and a programmer in this case to be excessively lenient.
As reported by "Kavkazsky Uzel", on November 8, it became known that a court in Kaspiysk sentenced three employees of the city administration, an MFC employee, and a programmer to restrictions on freedom for periods ranging from one to two years for unauthorized access to the accounts of six thousand residents on "Gosuslugi".
According to the case materials, in 2023, the accused obtained the logins and SNILS of residents, created temporary passwords, and organized voting on their behalf for public areas that were to be improved without the consent of the account owners. Residents of Dagestan, commenting on the verdict on social media, considered the punishment too lenient and expressed concerns about the security of personal data.
Manipulations with voting for the improvement of areas in Kaspiysk differ from election falsifications in that they became the initiative of local officials, noted journalist Vladimir Sevrinovsky. In his assessment, election result falsifiers in the North Caucasus do not have to resort to complex schemes, and the fight against violations turns into the persecution of observers.
"Those who falsify elections in the North Caucasus do not need to resort to complex manipulations – it is enough to submit randomly filled forms to the TEC. No responsibility threatens such violators. On the contrary, the movement of observers trying to prevent them has faced repression. Activist Eduard Ataev, who uncovered violations in the 2016 elections in Endirey, is serving a sentence of six years and five months – he allegedly had weapons and drugs found on him," Sevrinovsky told a correspondent of "Kavkazsky Uzel".
The officials of Kaspiysk were aware of such practices, however, acting independently, they had to use a more complex scheme, the journalist suggested.
"But what is permitted to Jupiter is not permitted to the bull. Acting independently, they had to resort to the scheme with accounts on "Gosuslugi", got caught, and gave the state the opportunity to show that it still punishes manipulators at least in some public votes," Sevrinovsky explained.
Access of outsiders to thousands of accounts on "Gosuslugi" raises concerns about the security of residents' personal data, the journalist emphasized.
"If malicious officials can easily gain access to thousands of accounts and conduct operations on behalf of people – it seems that an incorrectly counted vote is far from the most serious of possible consequences," the analyst concluded.
Manipulations with the accounts of residents of Kaspiysk cannot be considered a private case, as the practice of artificially inflating indicators during voting has developed over the years, believes the Dagestani journalist. In his opinion, such violations can occur not only in Dagestan but also in other regions of Russia.
"These manipulations are not a private case, but a system of vote rigging that has developed over the years both in determining the improvement of areas and in electronic voting <…>. And it has likely developed not only in Dagestan but also in other parts of the country," he stated to a correspondent of "Kavkazsky Uzel" on condition of anonymity.
Such cases undermine trust in electronic voting, the journalist believes. According to him, residents of Dagestan were already aware of the alleged manipulations, although they had no direct evidence. He also linked the criminal prosecution of Kaspiysk officials to changes in the city's leadership.
"Moreover, it has not been fully implemented in Dagestan. Such crimes are only suppressed by the authorities and law enforcement when they deem it necessary. That is, this is a one-off case. In the case of Kaspiysk, there is a task to remove unnecessary deputies of the city head, as part of Gontcov's team, and to reformat the construction market in that area," the journalist pointed out.
Manipulations with voting results and falsifications in the work of government institutions may be interconnected, the analyst suggested. He characterized such actions as manifestations of corruption.
"In this specific case, these are closely interconnected issues, the mechanism for forming indicators (unfulfilled work), allowing funds from the FOMS to be withdrawn through paperwork," he noted.
The team of the new head of Dagestan has the potential to fight such a system, but the result will depend on whether officials can abandon the practice of falsifications to demonstrate the effectiveness of their work, the journalist believes.
"They will be able to if they do not fall into the dependence of needing to show falsifications and results before Moscow and to demonstrate their own effectiveness," he summarized.
Information about the punishment of Kaspiysk officials spread in city chats, but the details of the case are not known to all local activists, reported a representative of the organization "Kaspiysk – our city" Svetlana Bagmet. She noted that falsifications also occur in the field of medical services when institutions inform patients about appointments with doctors and examinations that did not actually take place.
"Naturally, this is the case, and the reason is the write-off of OMC funds for the needs of clinics," Bagmet noted to a correspondent of "Kavkazsky Uzel".
Against the backdrop of the case of manipulations with voting in Kaspiysk, significant changes are occurring in the city's leadership, Bagmet pointed out. In her opinion, the circumstances of the criminal prosecution of former city officials, as well as decisions affecting the interests of residents, deserve a separate journalistic investigation.
"I would like a journalistic investigation into what is happening in Kaspiysk regarding the arrest of Mayor Gontcov, the chairman of the deputies Dzhavatov (three terms), who has been found to have 20 billion in movable and immovable property, and the repeated arrest of former architect Makhov.
The legality of the auction for the sale of the DK "Dagdiesel", which deprived residents of the only place of cultural attraction of republican scale. It is a pity that our media only indulge in momentary news and do not dig deeper. An interesting epic could be written about our city over the past 27 years, and the heroes are the same," Bagmet said.
For unauthorized access to computer information containing citizens' personal data, stricter penalties are provided than those assigned to the defendants in the Kaspiysk case, noted lawyer Timofey Shirokov. In his assessment, the actions of the convicted had signs that allow for the consideration of a more severe punishment.
"This article has a wide range of penalties. There are fines, restrictions on freedom, but there can also be imprisonment. According to the third part, with selfish interest, causing significant damage by a group of persons by prior agreement, using their official position – up to 6 years. These signs are present in their actions. It turns out they got off lightly with just restrictions on freedom," he told a correspondent of "Kavkazsky Uzel".
Falsifications of medical services that were not actually provided to patients can also lead to criminal liability, the lawyer explained. According to him, the legal qualification of such actions depends on their purpose.
"It all depends on the purpose. If it is for selfish gain, then it is fraud. Because it resembles manipulations with insurance payments. After all, each medical event is paid from the corresponding insurance fund," Shirokov pointed out.
Translated automatically via OpenAI from https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/428411








![Tumso Abdurakhmanov. Screenshot from video posted by Abu-Saddam Shishani [LIVE] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIR3s7AB0Uw Tumso Abdurakhmanov. Screenshot from video posted by Abu-Saddam Shishani [LIVE] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIR3s7AB0Uw](/system/uploads/article_image/image/0001/18460/main_image_Tumso.jpg)